Blog · Tryouts · October 28, 2026

Coaches, slow down. A tryout story.

A coach who had never met her asked a player to move five feet and change her platform in the middle of a tryout. What happened next is why we tell players to say thank you and play their game.

Coach Andor on YouTube: “The Five-Foot Mistake That Broke A Tryout”. The article below is the same idea, written out for parents.

What happened

At a tryout, a coach the player had never met walked over and asked her to move five feet and change how she held her platform. She did what she was told. Her passing fell apart for the rest of the session, and she left the tryout thinking she was a worse player than she was.

Why it fell apart

A skill a player has done thousands of times runs on its own. The moment she starts thinking about her body parts, it stops running on its own. Motor-learning research has shown this for twenty years: an internal focus, on the hands or the feet, gets in the way under pressure, and an external focus, on where the ball should go, keeps the movement automatic.

A tryout is the worst possible moment for a technical change. It is the one hour when a player most needs the skill she already has.

What we tell players

If a coach you do not know asks you to change something big in the middle of a tryout: say thank you, and keep playing the game that got you there. A good change is worth learning in practice next week, where it can become automatic before it has to hold up in front of an evaluator.

What we tell coaches

Slow down. Give the player a chance. Watch her play before you change her. The tryout is for seeing what she has, not for fixing it, and at St. Johns Volleyball Club that is how our own tryouts run: Coach Andor watches, then places.

More from the gym

All articles